Welcome to America’s Pie
At America’s Pie, we celebrate the rich flavors of Italian cuisine with a twist. Nestled in West Chester, PA, our restaurant offers a diverse menu that goes beyond pizza to include sandwiches and delectable sides, catering to various tastes, including many vegetarian options. We're proud of our casual atmosphere, where families can enjoy hearty meals together. From our crispy Garlic Knots to the crowd-favorite Chicken Cheesesteak, every dish is crafted with passion. After overcoming challenges, we're back and more dedicated than ever to delivering remarkable service and unforgettable flavors, making America’s Pie the go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike.
-
323 E Gay St Ste B2A West Chester, PA 19380 United States Hotline: (484) 947-5115
Welcome to America’s Pie, a vibrant culinary gem located at 323 E Gay St Ste B2A in West Chester, PA. Renowned for its extensive menu that seamlessly blends the best of Italian pizza, scrumptious sandwiches, and delightful appetizers, America’s Pie has garnered a loyal following that appreciates both flavor and value.
Dining Experience
Step inside to a casual dining environment, where the noise level is moderate and the atmosphere is buzzing with excitement. Whether you're looking to grab a quick bite for lunch or sit down for a hearty dinner with friends and family, America’s Pie fits the bill. With outdoor seating available and wheelchair accessibility, it caters to everyone. Plus, you can enjoy free Wi-Fi and catch up on the game on the TV while you savor your meal.
Menu Highlights
The menu boasts a wealth of options that cater to all tastes, including numerous vegetarian selections. Start your meal with an enticing appetizer like the Fried Ravioli topped with prosciutto and vodka sauce or the flavorful Bang Bang Shrimp, which comes on a bed of spring mix with mango salsa. With prices ranging from $6.49 to $16.49, there’s something for everyone.
- Signature Pizzas: Indulge in their generously sized pizzas, such as the classic Brooklyn or innovative combinations featuring fresh toppings that keep customers coming back.
- Salads: Fresh options like the Mediterranean Salad and Nutty Peach Salad are perfect for those seeking a lighter bite without sacrificing taste.
- Sandwiches: The menu shines with an array of sandwiches, including the highly praised Chicken Cheesesteak, celebrated for its rich flavor and satisfying texture.
Catering and Customer Experience
America’s Pie is also open to catering options, making it a great choice for gatherings, parties, or casual get-togethers. Customers have consistently praised the prompt and friendly service, often highlighting the restaurant's dedication to customer satisfaction. Reviewers like Morgan F. and Dave Z. have noted the attentive staff and swift service, making each dining experience enjoyable.
Heartfelt Resilience
A little backstory adds to the charm of America’s Pie. After enduring the challenges of a significant flooding incident in 2022, the team worked tirelessly to bounce back, proving both their resilience and their commitment to the West Chester community. As loyal customers like Zack S. can attest, their return has been met with excitement and gratitude.
Conclusion
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, America’s Pie promises a delightful dining experience filled with flavor, warmth, and the happy buzz of a community spot. With easy takeout and delivery options available, indulging in their culinary creations has never been easier. Come and see why America’s Pie is a beloved staple in West Chester—your taste buds will thank you!
This place has great pizza and REMARKABLE service. I tried a salad there for the first time and it was pretty good but I wouldn't go running back. Big menu though. Wide variety of slices available.
I really enjoy the food. The service at the counter is always pleasant and immediate. A top tier experience.
Don't get me wrong I'm not taking anything away from their sandwiches, all are great esp the chicken cheesesteak, or the pizza which is also great. But...the tacos and jalapeño crab soup here are why you should go.
Great spot! So many different options ranging from pizza to salad to dessert. Huge menu, fast service and great value for the portion size. Highly recommend.
The food was absolutely delicious, i had to slices if the tomato brooklyn. The workers were so nice and they are swifties so that is a bonus. And the resturant is full of Philadelphia sport team stuff
Great spot. Pizzas are large. Crisp. Yummy. Sandwich's tonsssss to choose from. Seeded rolls and regular. Nice people as well, called to confirm an order last night after a question. About an allergy. Appreciated that!
This is such a blessing in good ol' WC. Everything is sooo good. Tonight my husband and I had taco dinners. Delicious! (Recommended by one of my patients!) We had the West Coast and Calvario tacos. (One is battered haddock, the other slow cooked brisket) Great to share! Prices are so reasonable, too! Keep up the great work!
Great food that's very consistent. Got the plain Brooklyn with extra caramelized onions and it was so good! Fast and courteous delivery from the restaurant as well.
AMERICA's PIE IS BACK! After long time waiting for our go to pizza place in West Chester, they have returned from the Great Flood of '22! When we moved here a year ago and discovered this gem, it was like a match made in heaven for us pizza lovers! By the time we explored their sandwiches on their menu it happened... The Great Flood of '22. Long story short their place flooded from a random act of the devil himself; however, America's Pie persevered. With a very heart wrenching away message, they closed shop, picked up some mops, and got to work. Then they dried themselves off and opened up their door, more importantly their pizzas, to our little big town. Tonight I finally went back after over 3 months of waiting. I even stopped what slice of pizza to choose from, picked up my phone, and started writing this review before even TAKING A BITE IM THAT EXCITED! If you like good food, quick service, and hopefully still BANGING sandwiches, it's worth splurging the few extra bucks for America's Pie!
2nd time here. Cool vibe. Good food and chill staff. Really good cheesesteak! And check out my salad!